Aquatic Origins for Birds - "The Duck at the Bottom of the Tree" (Nature)

The duck at the bottom of the tree
"...The idea that all modern birds stem from an aquatic ancestor might come as a surprise, admits Chiappe. "If you look at the evolutionary tree of living birds, the most primitive are all land birds — ratites, ostrich, emu, pheasants," he says. "It seems that many lineages left the water and colonized the land."
But although many people think of ducks, geese and other waterfowl as specialized animals, they are quite primitive in comparison to highly evolved species such as songbirds, Chiappe points out.
What's more, almost every bird group alive today has representatives that live in or around water, Chiappe says, suggesting that a watery lifestyle may be an ancient tradition that has persisted in many lineages. Pelicans are not closely related to penguins; and neither bears a close kinship with herons, he adds.
That's not to say that all of today's aquatic birds are evolutionary throwbacks. Penguins, for example, are highly specialized for hunting in water while battling the polar cold. And Chiappe admits that the aquatic-origins theory could be cast into doubt if somebody finds a fossilized land bird of the same vintage as Gansus.
For now, though, the Chinese fossils remain our best indicator of what early modern birds might have looked like. Among the dozens of fossils, some even preserve remains of soft tissues, allowing the researchers to deduce that the creature had webbed feet.
Does this spectacular fossil haul indicate that the birds flew in groups? Lamanna is not sure, but says it is possible: "Many aquatic birds roam in flocks and settle down at lakes - maybe Gansus did too."
(Source)
China fossils fill out bird story
"... The detail in their preservation, such as the bone structure and even foot webbing, indicates the animals were well adapted to an aquatic existence.
Scientists say Gansus is the oldest known member of the group that includes modern birds.
They believe this makes its story a critical one in understanding the evolution of avian species.
"Every bird living today, from ostriches... to bald eagles, probably evolved from a Gansus-like ancestor," Matthew Lamanna, of Carnegie Natural History Museum in Pittsburgh, US, told a news conference on Thursday."
(Source)
"...One of the new fossils, from northwest China, even preserves the webbing between the toes. The finding, reported today in the journal Science, supports the notion that all living birds, from ostriches to ducks to hummingbirds, descended from an ancestor that lived by the shore." (Source)

"...But early bird fossils are of birds not yet fully adapted to long or powerful flight."

I am focusing on the evolution of flight, pre-flight -- how birds came to be "birds" -- not extinct by-product species which were failed evolutionary experiments, or even modern birds. I'm am only concerned with the actual ancestors, of living birds. The environmental dynamics which lead to the evolution of their anatomy, which gave rise to flight. The same physics (aerodynamics) involved with flight are found in hydrodynamics... I think birds anatomy is covered in clues that speak to their early aquatic origins.

"...Their skeletons are still reptilian in many respects, their keel bones in their body are not very long and could not have supported thick broad wing flapping muscles. Sure, they could glide and climb trees."

That is not in question,

"... "If you took most of the bones in its body, including famous pieces like the breastbone and the wishbone, and put them next to those of a modern bird, you'd have a lot of difficulty telling them apart," he told the BBC Radio 4's Leading Edge programme.
"Gansus would probably have looked very much like a grebe or a diver, or certain kinds of ducks. It had webbed feet and it had fairly powerful legs. We can tell that from looking at the bones in the knee area. This tells us it was a very well-adapted diving or swimming-type bird."
According to Harris, these adaptations all demonstrate how the Gansus branch of the family tree, the structurally modern birds called ornithuromorphs, split from the enantiornitheans (or "opposite birds").
Enantiornitheans were among the famous feathered fossils found in northeastern China during the 1990s.
The analysis implies that the line that would become modern birds left the land and became adapted to life on the water and then, at a later date, came back onto land."

No comments:

Post a Comment